Alina Kargin / Cases

Case 1, banking

The $15 billion loss that was only in a footnote

At the end of 2022 Silicon Valley Bank reported $16.0 billion of shareholders' equity. In the notes to the same report, bonds it carried at $91.3 billion were worth $76.2 billion. I wanted to understand how both numbers could be true at once.

By Alina Kargin. Every figure is from SVB's own annual report or the Federal Reserve's review.

$16.0BShareholders' equity on the balance sheet, December 31, 2022.SVB 10-K
$15.2BLoss on held-to-maturity bonds that was not on the balance sheet.SVB 10-K, securities note
$0.8BWhat is left of the equity if you subtract one from the other, before tax.My arithmetic

The accounting

The same bond, three places to put the loss

When a bank buys a bond it has to say what it plans to do with it. That one decision sets where a fall in price shows up, and for one category the answer is: almost nowhere.

Label the bank choosesCarried atA fall in price shows up in
TradingMarket valueNet income, right away
Available for saleMarket valueEquity, through other comprehensive income. Net income is untouched.
Held to maturityWhat the bank paidThe notes only. The balance sheet and the income statement do not move.

The logic is fair as far as it goes. If you really hold a bond until it matures, you get all your money back and the dip in between never cost you anything. The rule depends on one word: really.

The numbers

One year turned a $1 billion gap into $15 billion

Held-to-maturity bondsDec 31, 2021Dec 31, 2022
On the balance sheet (cost)$98.2B$91.3B
Market value, from the notes$97.2B$76.2B
Loss not on the balance sheet$1.0B$15.2B
Shareholders' equity as reported$16.2B$16.0B

Nothing was hidden. The market value sits in the securities note of the annual report, a few lines under the cost. During 2022 interest rates rose fast, old bonds paying low rates lost value, and reported equity barely moved, because of the label on the bonds.

Try it

How far do rates have to rise to use up the equity?

SVB carried $91.3 billion.
SVB reported 6.2 years for this portfolio. A year earlier it was 4.1.
Assumption. 2.7 points is roughly what reproduces the loss SVB reported.
SVB reported $16.0 billion.
Loss in the notes
Share of equity it would use
Equity if the bonds were marked
Rise in yields that uses all of it

The model uses the standard rule of thumb: a bond's price falls by about its duration times the rise in yield. It ignores tax and convexity, so it is an estimate, not SVB's actual valuation.

What happened next

"Held to maturity" lasted until the deposits left

The bonds were paid for with customer deposits, $173.1 billion of them at year end, and the Federal Reserve's review describes those deposits as largely uninsured. Money like that can leave in a day.

On March 8, 2023 the bank said it had sold $21 billion of its available-for-sale bonds at a $1.8 billion after-tax loss. On March 9 customers withdrew more than $40 billion. Management expected over $100 billion more the next morning. The bank was closed on March 10.

Once a bank has to sell, the label stops mattering. The loss in the footnote becomes a loss in cash.

What I take from it

Three things I now check in any bank's report

  1. Read the securities note, not just the balance sheet.Cost and market value are printed side by side. The subtraction takes ten seconds.
  2. Compare that gap with equity.A gap of 5% of equity is a detail. At SVB it was 95%.
  3. Ask who funds the bonds.Holding to maturity is a promise about years. It only works if the money behind it can also wait for years.

Sources

Where the numbers come from

All three casesAbout AlinaMessage me on LinkedIn